© 1980 by Institute of Chartered Foresters
Productivity of Closely-spaced Young Poplar on Agricultural Soils in Britain
Institute of Terrestrial Ecology Bush Estate, Midlothian, Scotland
Recent ideas on silage and fuel forestry call for more information on the total harvestable woody dry matter produced by hardwoods grown at very close spacings in fertile soils and coppiced every few years. Yields of oven-dried stems and branches (S and B) are presented here for Populus trichocarpa Torr. and Gray, clone Fritzi Pauley. Plantings in Bedfordshire at 21 600 trees ha1 had a mean annual increment (M.A.I.SB) of 5.2 t ha1 y1 over five years, and plantings in the Cambridgeshire fens at 1480 trees ha1 produced 4.8 t ha1 y1 over six years. Fan-shaped spacing experiments, established in Midlothian by inserting cuttings through black polythene into nursery soil with added fertilizers, gave 4.6 t ha1 y1 at the end of the first year and about 7 t ha1 y1 one year after coppicing, but only with over 250 000 stems ha1 producing closed canopies with leaf area indices of about 4. Similar spacing experiments planted without fertilizer on farmland in Gloucestershire, Suffolk, Argyll and Midlothian gave average M.A.I.SB values of 6.57.0 t ha1 y1 after three years with over 25 000 trees ha1 and similar values after five years with over 10 000 trees ha1. Peak current annual increments (C.A.I.SB) averaged 1012 t ha1 y1. The maximum M.A.I.SB, attained in Gloucestershire, was 10.0 t ha1 y1 at age 5 with over 20 000 trees ha1, with maximum C.A.I.SB values of about 14 t ha1 y1 at age 4; M.A.I.SB values of about 11.5 t ha1 y1 were anticipated at this site by age 68. Equivalent stem volumes are given. As expected, trees subjected to competition accumulated greater proportions of their woody biomass in stems rather than branches.
Biomass yields of fully-stocked young hardwood stands are independent of planting density. In Britain, M.A.I.SB values of 68 t ha1 y1 can be obtained over 1 or 25 years by planting 250 000 or 2000 trees ha1, using vigorous Populus spp, Salix spp or Nothofagus procera on good sites.
Advantages and problems of silage forestry are discussed, and it is considered that hardwood fuel coppices could not meet more than about 2% of national energy needs.
The reciprocals of individual tree weights were linearly related to planting density.